I ran across an article online yesterday that gave me a lot of reasons to think-both as a citizen and as the mother of a teenager. The article, headlined “Students Can Be Punished for Postings Online,” was in the Indianapolis Star. It concerned a local school board who had approved a new policy which “informs students and teachers that they will be held legally responsible for anything posted online, including material deemed defamatory, obscene, proprietary or legally libelous.”
The funny thing about all this is that, according to an article by an attorney in the American School Board Journal, titled “Slamming in Cyberspace,” this issue has already been pretty well covered by the courts in Indiana. Did this school board not research the issue throughly, or did they just feel a need to reinvent the wheel? However, the diligence (or lack thereof) by this school board is not the issue.
This is hardly the first time I have faced this issue. There has been a lot of recent controversy on this particular subject. It has also hit a bit closer to home for me. It was recently an issue at my daughter’s high school, concerning a student’s critical blog postings on one of his teachers and the principal.
Aside from the Constitutional issues involved here, I have another concern. As a social worker, I’ve worked in the juvenile justice system. There, I dealt with teens who felt isolated and ignored. They felt they had no one with whom to discuss their problems.
My question, as both a parent and a social worker, is “Do we want to take away what, for many teens, may be one of the few outlets they have to vent feelings like anger, frustration and fear?” My own answer, as both a parent and a social worker is “No. I, at least, do not.”
Consider this: A troubled teen, who is angry at someone (a teacher, friend, classmate, etc.) for whatever reason has few friends, feels that he cannot talk to his parents or to anyone else. He goes to his MySpace blog and posts about these feelings. This is, in a sense, his outlet, his support system. This is sad, but true, in some cases.
Are we really making this situation better by taking this away? Keeping such feelings pushed down and bottled up only makes this teen’s anger and frustration worse. Over a period of time, having not had any outlet in which to deal with his feelings, this teen explodes. Who knows what form this explosion may take? This particular teen may turn to alcohol or drugs. He/she may get into fights or consider (or even attempt) suicide.
Now, in an ideal world, we would want our teenager to be able to talk with his parents, a school counselor, a teacher-anyone who could help him or her, or get some professional help for the teen. But this is not an ideal world. The teen may feel that the anonymity of cyberspace is the safest place to turn.
In addition, this is an excellent example of how we, as parents, are allowing school and government to take away our parental rights and responsibility. We have a responsibility-both to our children and to society-to keep up with what our teenagers are doing. This includes keeping lines of communication open, so that, as well as sharing good things, our teens feel safe and comfortable sharing their problems with us. It is a big responsibility. It may seem overwhelming to some of us. If WE feel that way, think about how our teens feel.
Sources:
Indianapolis Star, Students Can Be Punished for Posting Online
American School Board Journal, Slamming in Cyberspace
teenagers, teens, blogging, MySpace, students, cyberspace, student discipline, posting